Book Reviews


Private Minds: 3 women, 3 cities, 2 generations - A psychiatrist shares a fictional case study of a family and its dynamics

Perma-link for article:

Ali's Book Choice: By Ali Khwaja

The author of the book 'Private Minds', Monica Bakre is a practicing counsellor and psychologist with many years of experience in both educational and health sectors

Learn to fight right, fight fair
It is not very often that we get to read a narration that takes us into the deepest minds of people, through the eyes of a therapist. Though this book is fiction, it is very useful reading for anyone who wants to understand human behaviour, particularly how relationships change, flourish and get destroyed within the family and outside.

The author, a practicing counsellor and psychologist with many years of experience in both educational and health sectors, has weaved a tale of three women of one family, and their interaction with a very sensitive and humane psychiatrist. The young psychiatrist, who is the narrator of the story, is frank in expressing his own feelings, doubts, uncertainties along with his expertise as a therapist trying to help them find their identity.

In a simple and narrative style, the story takes us through three cities and two generations, giving a deep insight into how life unfolds, how circumstances and people change, and what the needs of such people are.

This book is also very useful reading for budding counsellors, both professional and lay persons who wish to sharpen their skills of understanding and dealing with the dynamics of human relationships. It also comforts the reader to the fact that even a highly qualified and experienced psychiatrist is also human when it comes to the matter of the heart. Thus the reader ends the narration with a warm feeling that “Aaall izzz well” despite all the ups and downs and the challenges that life throws at us.

Please note: Private Minds has been written by Monica Bakre who is one of the earliest alumni of Banjara Academy's Diploma in Counselling Skills (DCS) course. She went on to do her Diploma in Life Skills, Masters in Psychotherapy, and was the first from Banjara Academy to be employed by the Ministry of Defence in the Indian Air Force Command Hospital as a clinical psychologist.
Book (Rs 275/-) available at:


My Experiments with Truth

Mahatma GandhiAs a college student long ago I had read My Experiments with Truth, the autobiography of Mahatma Gandhi. I adored him and his qualities, but could not learn much from the book. This year I read it again. My respect for the great soul went up higher, because now I could see him as a simple, struggling, confused and exploring human being. Yet I could learn so much from his ‘experiments’, including the fact that he mentioned he should not be writing his autobiography while he is alive, because putting down his thoughts in writing will prevent him from changing his thinking or approach later.

Mahatma GandhiYet, he constantly changed his attitude. From being an ardent admirer of the British Raj, to becoming its greatest nemesis; hiding from his father and eating mutton to becoming such a staunch vegetarian that he declined to drink milk (one of the first vegans I suppose!). The beauty is that he never hesitated in admitting all his mistakes, page after page in his elaborate book. Nowhere do we see a hint of self-praise, or description of achievements, from the pen of a person who the whole world recognized as a ‘Mahatma’.

This book I am told is the world’s highest selling autobiography. And I am also told, that despite its highly subsidized price in India, his home country is one where the book does not sell much. What is the lesson we learn from this, can we introspect? After all we get a full day’s holiday on 2nd October to think.

By Ali Khwaja



Skills and Qualities for Effective Life

The book, Skills and Qualities for Effective Life, is written by Dr. S. Ignacimuthu, SJ, and published by Better Yourself Books (Rs. 170/-).

Topic-wise tips to improve life for yourself and for others

An amazing author, a Jesuit priest, a renowned scientist in the field of entomology, and a very humble human being – the right person to talk about how life can be made more effective.

The book contains 77 very concise chapters, each dealing with all important aspects of life, providing practical and easily practicable tips and tools. A significant point is that he has touched upon areas where one can improve oneself rather than trying to change the world. For example, he talks about how to make yourself trustworthy, rather than finding out how to trust (or distrust) others. He gives tips on how to receive feedback from others, rather than how to give feedback (read criticism) to others. Many chapters deal with self-belief, self-acceptance, self-examination and self-image. At the same time he shows us how to be a risk-taker, or how to keep trying.

Without in any way sermonizing or trying to preach to the reader, Fr. Ignacimuthu has brought out amazingly good methods to work upon ourselves, to accept responsibility, and to be pro-active in making our life better – regardless of the challenges or setbacks that we may have.

This is not a book to be read and set aside. It can be a bedside companion to end the day in introspection, a breakfast treat to face the day with greater vigour, or a mid-day energizer to stop routine work and think deeper into our life. Practicing each of these very practical inputs can actually bring in a marked change for the better, whether it is a teenager student, or a senior citizen. A must read, must keep, and must keep reading, book.



Parenting - The art and science of nurturing

bookAuthored by Dr. Shekhar Seshadri and Nirupama Rao, and published by Byword Books (Rs. 250/-), lives up to its blurb Children are nature’s gift to mankind, and how we raise them is our gift to the world.

A rare book that does not resort to any jargon, balances the needs of children and parents very rationally, and yet goes into the depth of emotional well being. While it draws extensively from the principles of the famous Rudolf Steiner, it also projects the Indian family scenario, with insightful case studies that make the reader sit up and think.

Almost every aspect of parenting, from common issues such as discipline, learning, self esteem to generation gap and sibling rivalry has been dealt with in a simple but practical manner, giving specific tips to parents to handle different and difficult situations. The book also covers adoption, grief, sexuality and value education, which are the need of the hour.


This book is a reminder to parents on issues that are known cognitively but often neglected in practice e.g. the importance of touch, respecting the child’s choices, acknowledging unique learning styles, to name a few.

Teaching and giving a good upbringing to kids has been quoted very well – All people are learners. The challenge is to determine the kind, amount and pace of learning that benefits different individuals, whether they are intellectually, developmentally or physically challenged. Every person loves to learn and wants to learn, but with dignity and freedom.

This book is a useful tool to adults who wish to keep learning how to provide better learning and growth to kids.


Page 1 of 2


Do you want to study online to be a Certified Professional Counsellor - to counsel, reach out to people needing emotional support?

NEW October 2015 BATCH: Telephonic Interviews ON for our completely Online International Graduate Diploma in Counselling Skills (IGDCS) course.

Schedule your phone interview - just call up Sreedhar, 09901625390, or Ranveer, 07813088889. Or, provide your name & mobile no. below; we'll SMS you for time to interview you.

FREE Online Psychological Counselling by Banjara Academy for anyone, anywhere in the world FREE online counselling for the depressed

  • Are you stressed about your child?
  • Is your marriage in trouble?
  • Are you stressed about your education?
  • Do you feel overwhelmed by anxiety and fear?

Just mail your counsellor now, sharing your problems, your worries, your anxieties, your fears. Your counsellor will reply to you, and be there for you until you need her to help you cope and get going.

Sreedhar, Director of Online Courses and Online Counselling by email of Banjara AcademyLeading Banjara Academy's online email counselling team of volunteer-counsellors, I realize it is not an easy task reaching out to a person one has never met, never seen, without the added advantage of gestures, eye contact, a gentle reassuring touch, tone of voice and yet providing empathy, positive strokes, making the person feel heard and understood.

With the aid of only written words, it is quite a task building trust, making people open up and share and helping them cope and feel better. So when in many instances they write back saying thank you and that they feel so much better, the feeling one gets is priceless and incomparable - knowing one has done something right, something good!

Hats off to all the volunteeer-counsellors of Banjara Academy who have been carrying on this work silently, anonymously for the last couple of years. Truly commendable! - Sreedhar MA

Image Credit: J3SSL33,, Creative Commons Attribution 2.0 License
This website was initially conceived and designed by the late Sitaram N
Copyright © 2015 Creative Commons License
Except where otherwise noted, the Content of the Website of Banjara Academy - the text, the audios, the videos, the images - contributed by Dr Ali Khwaja and his team of volunteers at Banjara Academy is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.